Skip to Main Content

SQL & PL/SQL

Announcement

For appeals, questions and feedback about Oracle Forums, please email oracle-forums-moderators_us@oracle.com. Technical questions should be asked in the appropriate category. Thank you!

GROUP BY clause diff in Sybase and Oracle

500237Mar 16 2009 — edited Mar 17 2009
Hi,

I am migrating code from Sybase to Oracle and came across a strange issue which is widely known to others :)
In Sybase , one can use columns or calculations in the SELECT expressions that don't appear
in the GROUP BY clause of the query. Like

SELECT order.custid,customer.name,MAX(payments)
-> FROM order, customer
-> WHERE order.custid = customer.custid
-> GROUP BY order.custid;
works fine but for SQL we need to add customer.name to GROUP BY clause.

On the similar lines, here is my SQL query

INSERT INTO GTT_CTRT_recalc_proc
(id_fin_rec,
id_imnt,
id_instr_opn,
dt_instr_opn,
dt_opn,
dt_cls_loanet,
dt_prcss,
am_invst)
SELECT t1.id_fin_rec,
t1.id_imnt,
t1.id_instr_opn,
t1.dt_instr_opn,
t1.dt_opn,
NVL(t1.dt_cls_loanet, l_dt_to),
t1.dt_prcss,
SUM(t2.am_invst) + (0.123 * (1 - abs(sign(0 - SUM(t2.am_invst)))))
FROM GTT_CTRT_TEMP_recalc_process t1, GTT_CTRT_TEMP_recalc_process t2
WHERE t2.id <= t1.id
AND t2.id_imnt = t1.id_imnt
AND t2.id_instr_opn = t1.id_instr_opn
AND t2.dt_instr_opn = t1.dt_instr_opn
GROUP BY t1.id_imnt,
t1.id_instr_opn,
t1.dt_instr_opn,
t1.dt_opn,
t1.dt_cls_loanet,
t1.dt_prcss;

Which does not have t1.id_fin_rec in GROUP BY failing it in SQL.

I know that if I add this column in GROUP BY it will work fine but I am told to keep the functionality as it is as the result before and after adding the column would be diff of-course.

Please guide me about what can be done in this situation and is there any work around for this?

Thanks,
Aashish
This post has been answered by 189821 on Mar 16 2009
Jump to Answer
Comments
Locked Post
New comments cannot be posted to this locked post.
Post Details
Locked on Apr 14 2009
Added on Mar 16 2009
3 comments
530 views